✦ Complimentary UPS Ground Shipping on Orders Over $75 ✦
✦ Devonshire Residents Enjoy Complimentary Local Delivery Every Tuesday & Friday ✦
✦ Ember Club — First Access to Seasonal Releases & Limited Editions ✦
Search
0 Cart
Search
0 Cart

Find your sweet luxury...

Two Peanut Butter Reserve cookies from TNT Sweets made with Madasgar vanilla on a white linen napkin on a white marble surface.

The Peanut Butter Reserve

$25.00 - $95.00

Browse the Studio Stationery Gallery

Peanut butter done with intention.

Built around rich roasted peanut butter, The Peanut Butter Reserve delivers a soft center, gently structured edge, and a finish that's smooth without ever becoming heavy.

No excess sweetness. No shortcuts.

Just a peanut butter cookie refined to its final form.

Crafted in small batches and individually sealed from the moment it leaves the studio.

Curated Pairings — Enjoy alongside an ice-cold glass of milk, a freshly pulled espresso, a velvety mocha, a well-aged bourbon, or Oloroso Sherry.

Gold Stripe Wrap

  • Six-Piece · 4" × 2" × 9"
  • Twelve-Piece · 4" × 2.5" × 13"

Black Keepsake Box

  • Six-Piece · 6" × 6" × 3"
  • Twelve-Piece · 8" × 8" × 3"
  • Twenty-Four-Piece · 8" × 8" × 3"

Every cookie is individually sealed to preserve freshness. Follow the recommendations below for the best experience.

Storing Your Cookies

  • Best enjoyed within 48 hours of arrival. If saving for later, freeze in original packaging.
  • To store at room temperature, transfer to an airtight container for up to one week.
  • Avoid refrigerating — it draws out moisture and dries the cookies quickly.

Serve & Enjoy

  • To defrost, leave cookies wrapped at room temperature for approximately one hour.
  • For that fresh-baked warmth, warm in a 350°F oven for 5–10 minutes or microwave for 5–10 seconds.
  • Lemon cookies are oven-sensitive — the glaze will melt. Enjoy at room temperature or with a brief microwave warm.

Allergen Information
Contains wheat, milk, and eggs. Prepared in a kitchen that also processes soy, peanuts, and tree nuts.

Nutritional Profile: Each 43g (1 Cookie) contains approximately 190 calories.

Artisanal Ingredients: Natural Peanut Butter (Peanuts, Contains 1% or Less of Salt), Organic Bread Flour (certified 100% organic wheat flour, certified 100% organic malted barley flour), Organic Brown Sugar, Organic Cane Sugar, Organic Brown Eggs, Kosher Unsalted Sweet Cream Butter, Non-GMO Corn Syrup, Pure Vanilla Extract (Water, Alcohol, Sugar, Vanilla Bean Extractives), Baking Soda, Pure Kosher Sea Salt

Allergen Assurance Contains: [Wheat, Dairy, Eggs]. Prepared in an artisanal Studio that also handles tree nuts and soy.

Perfect Pairings